A holistic approach: A paradigm shift in quality control in mortgage lending

In the modern context of the mortgage industry, quality control (QC) stands as an important pillar supporting the integrity and stability of the industry. As market conditions change and regulatory scrutiny increases, lenders must adopt a comprehensive QC approach that goes beyond compliance check boxes. Consolidated Analytics’ Ed Gerding offers recommended strategies and best practices for elevating lenders’ QC programs from adequate to exceptional.

The holistic approach: A paradigm shift in quality management

The traditional view of QC as a post-closure audit function is rapidly becoming obsolete. Ed Gerding, CMB, advocates a more integrated strategy: “An integrated approach is critical for lenders to reduce financial, operational, and reputational risk,” he explains. This approach incorporates QC principles throughout the lending process, from application to service.

Key components of a complete QC program include:

1. Organizational Structure: Ensuring independence from production pressures
2. Personnel and Management: Hiring experienced professionals with proven track records
3. Training: Applying and maintaining rigorous, up-to-date training principles
4. Policies and Procedures: Regularly updated to reflect current market conditions and investor needs
5. Reporting: Developing a comprehensive analysis that highlights trends and high-risk areas
6. Vendor management: Maintaining supervision of outsourced QC activities

Using these elements creates a framework that not only catches mistakes but prevents them from happening in the first place.

Seasonal lulls as opportunities to improve QC

The cyclical mortgage industry presents challenges and opportunities for improving QC. As Gerding notes, “It usually goes into November and then during the winter months, the loan amount goes down a little bit.” Rather than viewing this as a setback, forward-thinking lenders can use this opportunity to their advantage.

In slow periods, lenders must:

• Conduct a comprehensive audit of their QC systems
• Review policies and procedures
• Provide additional training to employees
• Use new technology to improve QC processes

By investing in these areas during the lull, lenders position themselves for success when the market starts to recover.

Effective quality control capabilities

One of the most important changes in QC philosophy is from functional techniques to functional techniques. Gerding emphasizes this point: “An effective QC program really wants to identify and mitigate risks before they become a serious problem.” This approach involves analyzing data from post-closure reviews to identify pre-funding choice samples.

Using an effective QC strategy yields several benefits:

• Reduction in loan defaults
• Improved loan quality
• Improved investor confidence
• Repurchase risk

Lenders who use this forward-thinking approach often find themselves ahead of the curve in terms of loan quality and compliance.

Overcoming common pitfalls of QC

Even well-intentioned QC programs can be flawed if they do not address certain critical areas. Another common oversight, according to Gerding, is inadequate reporting: “More often than not, QC reporting could be improved by adding a higher summary section.” This summary should be error-prone over time and across all types of reviews, giving managers a clear, concise view of loan production quality.

Other potential pitfalls include:

• Insufficient sample sizes
• Lack of integration between pre-financing and post-closing QC
• Failure to act on QC results
• Inconsistent application of QC standards across channels or different products

By addressing these issues head on, lenders are significantly strengthening their QC programs and risk management strategies.

The importance of data integrity

In an era where data drives decision making, ensuring the accuracy and completeness of loan data is critical. “Data integrity is key to successfully managing the quality of loan originations for lenders,” said Gerding. This focus is consistent with Fannie Mae’s QC requirements and reflects the growing importance of data in the lending process.

Strategies to improve data integrity include:

• Using automated data validation tools
• Performing regular data checks
• Training staff on the importance of accurate data entry
• Establish clear data management policies

By prioritizing data integrity, lenders not only improve their QC results but also position themselves to leverage advanced analytics and machine learning technologies in the future.

Adjusting QC for lenders of all sizes

While larger institutions may have greater resources to devote to QC, smaller credit unions and private mortgage bankers face unique challenges. However, Gerding emphasizes that size should not be a barrier to effective QC: “It is still important that they access their QC plans to make sure they have everything covered from a regulatory and agency requirement perspective.”

Small lenders can improve their QC programs by:

• Using technology to automate certain QC tasks
• Outsourcing certain QC tasks to specialized vendors
• Focusing on high-risk areas identified through data analysis
• Collaborate with industry peers to share best practices

By taking these steps, even lenders with limited resources can develop robust QC programs that reduce risk and ensure compliance.

Preparing for the future of mortgage QC

As the industry looks ahead, several trends may shape the future of mortgage QC:

1. Automation Expanded: Machine learning and AI will play a major role in identifying potential defects and anomalies.
2. Real Time QC: The line between pre-funding and post-closure QC will blur as technology allows for more real-time quality checks.
3. Advanced Data Analytics: Predictive modeling will help lenders identify potential problems before they happen.
4. Regulatory Technology (RegTech): Specialized tools to help lenders stay compliant with ever-changing regulations.

Gerding advises lenders to stay flexible and be prepared: “When rates drop and startup volume increases rapidly, it will be very important to make sure you have the right number of staff for your quality control, compliance, and internal audit functions, such as staffing levels. they have declined in volume for the past few years. “

As the mortgage industry continues to evolve, a comprehensive and flexible approach to quality control will be essential for lenders looking to thrive in a competitive market. By adopting comprehensive strategies, effective technology, and staying ahead of industry trends, lenders can turn their QC programs into a real competitive advantage.

Related