Is technology the problem, not the solution, in the mortgage industry?

The mortgage industry has long been promised a revolution in technology to streamline workflow, reduce operating costs, and improve efficiency. However, despite huge investments in new technology, the cost of credit initiation has increased dramatically. Companies still face cyclical hiring and firing, and the expected return on investment (ROI) from technology implementation still needs to be realized. This raises an important question: Is technology failing the mortgage industry, or are we approaching it wrong?

Promise versus reality

Great expectations

Technology providers have marketed their solutions as panaceas for industry inefficiencies for a long time. They promise improved workflow, reduced costs, and simplified loan origination processes.

Rising costs

Contrary to expectations, mortgage origination costs have risen, reaching record highs in recent years. Instead of reducing costs, investment in technology has sometimes added layers of complexity and cost.

Continuous cycles

The industry continues its pattern of expansion and contraction of the workforce in response to market fluctuations. Despite technological advances, companies still resort to hiring and firing cycles, which shows that important issues must be addressed.

Why technology is not delivering the expected ROI

1. Indirect Solutions

• Workflow Band-Aids: Many technology products deal with high-level symptoms rather than basic system problems. Solutions tend to simplify individual tasks but need to be fully integrated with existing processes.

• Complex Manufacturing: The time and resources required to implement a new technology can reduce any potential benefits. Complex systems may require extensive training and maintenance periods.

2. The Human Factor Is Neglected

• Resistance to Change: Workers may refuse to use new tools, especially if they feel that those tools threaten job security. This resistance can lead to low levels of adoption and underutilization of the technology.
• Technology vs. Human Expertise: Automated systems cannot replicate senior professionals’ decision-making and relationship-building skills. The human touch is still important in mortgage lending.

3. Overemphasis on Technology as a Silver Bullet

• Ignoring Process Improvement: Relying solely on technology without redesigning basic processes limits efficiency. Technology should enhance, not replace, sound business processes.

• Reducing Training Needs: Inadequate training can lead to slow implementation of new systems. With the right understanding, employees can make full use of technology.

Cyclical recruitment and brainwashing

• Market sensitivity
  • Lending companies often respond to market changes with quick staff adjustments. This reaction leads to instability and the need for constant technology within organizations.

• Short-term focus
  • Addressing financial stress immediately through personnel changes undermines long-term stability. It prevents the development of skilled workers who can adapt to new technologies and market conditions.

• The role of technology
  • Instead of stabilizing the workforce, investment in technology sometimes exacerbates instability due to upfront costs without immediate payoff. Companies may cut staff to reduce these costs, reducing the potential benefits of new initiatives.

Is technology a problem?

• Not the technology itself
  • The problem may be something other than the technology per se but how it is chosen, how it is used, and how it is integrated. Misunderstanding between technical solutions and business needs leads to disappointing results.

• Strategic alignment is required
  • Technology should support well-defined business strategies, not replace them. A clear vision and strategic goals are critical to successful technology adoption.

• Human-centered design
  • Solutions need to be designed with the end user in mind, developed instead of replacing human labor. Staff input and consultation is essential during the development and implementation phases.

Moving forward: Rethinking the use of technology

Comprehensive needs assessment

• Find the Core Problems
  1. Do a thorough analysis to understand root problems before looking for technical solutions. This ensures that the technology addresses the real needs of the organization.

• Employee Engagement
  1. Involve employees at all levels to gain insight into real-world challenges and opportunities. Employee buy-in can improve adoption rates and increase the benefits of new systems.

The process of reengineering

• Configure Before Automate
  1. Improve existing processes to ensure that technology increases efficiency rather than automating inefficiency. This step prevents the focus of faulty processes.

• Change Management
  1. Create strong strategies for managing the human side of technology change. Support, training, and clear communication can ease transitions and improve acceptance.

Strategic technology partnership

• Collaborative Development
  1. Work with technology providers to develop solutions that fit the company’s unique needs. Collaboration ensures that technology aligns with business goals and operational realities.

• Long Term Commitment
  1. View technology adoption as a long-term investment that requires ongoing support and evolution. Continuous improvements and updates keep the systems compatible and efficient.

The conclusion

The mortgage industry’s challenges with technology adoption highlight a critical mismatch between expectations and reality. It takes more than technology to solve deep operational problems or to replace the critical work of human workers. Instead, companies should adopt a balanced approach that integrates technology as a tool within a broader strategy that focuses on process improvement and human resource development. By doing so, the industry can begin to realize the promised efficiencies and cost reductions that have not been achieved until now.

Call to action

• Industry collaboration
  • Stakeholders should come together to share best practices and improve technology adoption standards. Collaboration can lead to more effective solutions that benefit the entire industry.
• Continuous learning
  • Invest in training and development to ensure teams can effectively use new technology. An experienced workforce is critical to maximizing ROI on technology investments.
• Re-evaluates ROI metrics
  • When evaluating technology investments, shift the focus from short-term returns to long-term value creation. A long-term vision promotes sustainable growth and development.

Ryan Colkitt is Vice President of Product Management at AppraisalVision

This column does not necessarily reflect the opinion of HousingWire’s editorial department and its owners.

To contact the editor responsible for this piece: [email protected]

Related